Resilience is routinely offered as something people should acquire. It is thoughtfully packaged as a half-day workshop with a catering budget and a facilitator who has run the same exercise with forty other organisations. On first blush the logic that underpins this familiar move sounds reasonable enough: strain is a matter of personal capacity, and surely capacity can be topped up with a thoughtfully packaged workshop. A recent attempt to measure resilience across Australia points somewhere else.
The Australian Resilience Index, published by Zurich with Mandala Partners, RedBridge and Accent Research, draws on more than two million public and proprietary data points to measure the resilience of about 2,500 local communities across health, financial, social and environmental domains.(1) Financial resilience has the strongest relationship with the overall rating, and the ten highest-scoring communities are all driven by a Very High financial score. The pattern reads less like a ranking of capacity than a map of who has hospitals within reach, surplus money in reserve and people around them with whom they can connect.
Before continuing, there are a few caveats we should nevertheless keep front of mind: the index rates places, and a team is not a postcode. Its bands are built from relative rankings, so ‘Very High’ tells you where a community sits against the others and not how it would hold together should something break. Nothing in it suggests unassailable diagnostic power, and the discussion below borrows its categories as an analogy and not as a method.
This piece began as a conversation on a podcast and keeps some of that ‘looseness’ on purpose. The report works here as a provocation. And it’s a good one, because it is hard to read without asking what the equivalent finding would be about our own colleagues.
Critical writing on the rise of resilience in security and public policy argues that the language deployed trains people to treat exposure to threat as a permanent condition and their own adaptation as the answer, which hands the work of coping to the people on whom the threat lands.(2) Philosophical writing on the burnout society makes a related point about workplaces: they may recruit people into exploiting themselves, so that exhaustion passes for ambition.(3)
Ask for ‘resilience’ at an offsite and the recommendation is usually that people produce more of it. The index points in a different direction, and so does work on the social ecology of resilience, which argues that what looks like an individual trait depends heavily on the resources an environment makes available to the person.(4) With that in mind, it is quite possible the capacity people bring in on a Monday morning is largely delivered to them, or withheld from them, long before they walk through their employer’s doors.
You may notice how close this sits to your own team. Someone is running on a reserve the organisation had nothing to do with – a partner’s income, a parent they care for, a mortgage that has just become more expensive, a body that recuperates more slowly than it once did. Someone else has none of those and carries a different load. A team’s resilience is partly imported, and leaders rarely get to examine the consignment note. It can present as a slower recovery from a bad week or a thinner margin for a change of plan, well before it appears in anything a report would capture.
The index also contains a puzzle that anyone running a team will find familiar. Males are about 60% more likely than females to rate High or Very High on social resilience, and yet they report greater feelings of isolation in every age group, particularly after 35. Separately, the sharpest rate of Low or Very Low social resilience in any age group (20%) sits among Australians aged 35 to 49, a stretch of life in which many people carry the most at work and at home. The report does not explain the first finding, and we won’t pretend otherwise. Volunteering and community participation are among the things it counts, which may capture visible connection well and felt connection poorly. A team can look sociable on every measure a manager can see and still contain people who would describe their week quite differently if asked a different set of questions.
Organisational research is more usable here than the index. A re-analysis of the 1949 Mann Gulch bushfire, in which thirteen men died as their crew’s shared understanding of what was happening came apart, proposed several sources of resilience, among them improvisation and norms of respectful interaction.(5) The last of those doesn’t need the disclosure of a bank balance. How people treat each other when something goes wrong can be observed, discussed and changed by a team in the room.
A second borrowing comes from further away. In psychoanalytic writing on early development, the ‘holding environment’ names the surrounding care a person depends on before they can look after themselves.(6) A manager is not a parent, and infant development is the wrong place to take the idea literally, but it stretches usefully. Some of what looks like a person’s resilience is carried for them by the people and arrangements around them, and the carrying only becomes visible when it stops. A leader sits inside that environment whether they intend to or not.
The comparison comes from some early research of nursing services in hospital wards. A study published in 1960 found that the routines and fixed hierarchy of the service had developed into a defence against the anxiety of the work, and that in some respects they worked against both the nurses and the patients.(7) A resilience initiative can do the same job in an office. A survey, a wellbeing week or a Friday check-in can become the thing an organisation does so that it need not ask how the work itself depletes its people – a little like an announcement patting itself on the back as it walks out of the room. A form of corporate virtue signalling, if you will. The people running these activities are usually well-intentioned. The pattern is what deserves repeated scrutiny.
How the conversation is held may matter more than its content. A team resilience survey sent with a Friday deadline adds to the load it claims to measure. A conversation in which the leader speaks up, acknowledging the conditions of the work and not the circumstances of anyone’s life, allowing each person to decide how much of themselves to bring, is more likely to get somewhere. A community average says very little about any individual inside it, and a team average is no different, so the aim is to understand what the work asks of people and not to infer what is happening in their homes.
A handful of questions a team might use, in whatever order the conversation allows:
- When we say someone is coping well, what is carrying them that we cannot see?
- Which of our routines exist to make us feel we have dealt with strain, and which actually reduce it?
- Where do we look sociable yet feel disconnected, and who would tell us when this happens?
- What would we cut first if everyone on the team had a little less to spare for the next Quarter?
- Who here is holding the rest of us, and who holds them?
The index takes the measure of a country from the outside. A team can only measure itself from within. The first test is whether people will speak honestly about what the work costs them, and whether a leader is prepared to listen.
This piece grew out of a conversation on Leadership Decanted, the podcast hosted by New River’s Director, Paul Garcia and Kerry ‘KG’ Butler. You can listen to “Some surprising stats: Tracking our resilience as a population” (Cheeky Half, Episode 44, Season 6) here.
Endnotes
- Zurich Australia, Mandala Partners, RedBridge, & Accent Research. (2026). The Australian Resilience Index. Zurich Australia. https://www.zurich.com.au/latest-news/australian-resilience-index
- Evans, B., & Reid, J. (2014). Resilient life: The art of living dangerously. Polity.
- Han, B.-C. (2015). The burnout society (E. Butler, Trans.). Stanford University Press.
- Ungar, M. (2011). The social ecology of resilience: Addressing contextual and cultural ambiguity of a nascent construct. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 81(1), 1-17.
- Weick, K. E. (1993). The collapse of sensemaking in organizations: The Mann Gulch disaster. Administrative Science Quarterly, 38(4), 628-652.
- Winnicott, D. W. (1960). The theory of the parent-infant relationship. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 41, 585-595.
- Menzies, I. E. P. (1960). A case-study in the functioning of social systems as a defence against anxiety: A report on a study of the nursing service of a general hospital. Human Relations, 13(2), 95-121. For the wider tradition of applying this thinking to organisations, see Obholzer, A., & Roberts, V. Z. (Eds.). (1994). The unconscious at work: Individual and organizational stress in the human services. Routledge.
- Chemaly, S. (2024). The resilience myth: New thinking on grit, strength, and growth after trauma. Atria Books.
PG