This article is an extended exploration of this Greek myth as sensemaker, first introduced in a previous article.
Orpheus’s music is good enough to do what no mortal’s has ever done: move Hades and Persephone to pity him. They grant him Eurydice back from the underworld, on one condition. It’s a small but very precise condition. He must walk ahead of her out of the underworld and not turn to check she’s following until they have both reached the surface. (Interestingly this is not the first time this prohibition has appeared in a mythology story. Take Lot’s wife, for example.) Orpheus complies almost the entire distance. But right at the end, within sight of daylight, he turns. Out of love, or doubt, or simple human impatience, it hardly matters which. Eurydice is pulled back into the underworld a second time, permanently, and this time there is no third chance.
He doesn’t recover from it well. He refuses the company of other women afterward, entirely, and wanders in grief until a group of Maenads, followers of Dionysus enraged by his refusal of them, tear him apart. His severed head and lyre are thrown into a river and carried out to sea and, the story insists, his head is still singing as it floats, all the way to the shore of the island of Lesbos. Even in death, his devotion to what he lost doesn’t fully end. And that version of loyalty becomes its own kind of trap, and Orpheus lives, and dies, inside it.
There’s an obvious lesson here, and a second, harder one sitting under the surface. The first is what verification actually costs (in Orpheus’ scenario, that verification is literally ‘proof of life’). It does not cost nothing, which is how due diligence usually gets treated, but raises a genuine risk that isn’t evenly distributed across every kind of decision. Some things can be checked, revisited and corrected without real damage. Others are wrecked by the act of checking itself: the premature audit that signals distrust before there was any reason for it, the quiet agreement re-litigated one meeting too many times, the new hire’s judgement double-checked so often they never actually get to exercise it. The condition imposed on Orpheus wasn’t arbitrary. Looking back was the one action that could undo the very thing it was meant to protect.
The second, perhaps deeper lesson, is what happens after the loss. With regards to Orpheus’ story, it’s an ending less often discussed or understood. Grief that refuses to move on, that keeps refusing every other possibility out of loyalty to what’s gone, can itself become organisationally expensive. A failed initiative, a departed leader, a strategy the team invested in and then had to abandon – these all deserve (even demand) real mourning. And it doesn’t call for a permanent refusal of whatever comes next. Orpheus’s story doesn’t end with the second loss. It ends with the cost of never letting that second loss be the end.
Bion’s account of containment describes how a group needs to be able to hold and process something painful without either denying it or being overwhelmed by it, and a team that has genuinely lost something, a person, a plan, a version of itself, needs somewhere to put that loss that isn’t either pretending it didn’t happen or refusing everything that comes after it. The underworld closes over Eurydice either way. What’s actually within a team’s control is what it does with the ‘walk back to the surface.’
One practice worth trying.
Before checking on a decision, a hire, or an agreement that’s already been made, ask one question first: what would checking cost if it turns out there was nothing wrong? If the genuine answer is that checking itself would damage trust, delay momentum, or signal doubt that wasn’t there before, treat that as data, not as an obstacle to ignore. Separately, when a team is genuinely grieving a real loss, a failed project, a departure, a plan that had to be abandoned, name a point at which mourning it becomes refusing to move past it, and agree on that point together rather than letting it drift.
The walk out of the underworld only works if it’s finished before it’s checked. A team that learns to tell the difference between reasonable caution and the ‘look back’ that costs everything has learned something Orpheus never managed to learn.
And if you’re interested in more curated leadership development insights in the future, join our community here.
Sources
Bion, W. R. (1962). Learning from experience. Heinemann.
Fry, S. (2019). Heroes: The myths of the Ancient Greek heroes retold. Penguin/Michael Joseph.
Ovid. (1986). Metamorphoses (A. D. Melville, Trans.). Oxford University Press.
PG